Should Lewis Hamilton have retired from F1 already?

https://cdn.racingnews365.com/2025/Hamilton/_1800x945_crop_center-center_75_none/XPB_1372531_HiRes.jpg?v=1758207924

A difficult Ferrari debut reignites the retirement debate

Lewis Hamilton’s first season with Ferrari has been a grind, with the seven-time World Champion still awaiting his first podium for the Scuderia. After years of headline-making success in the 2010s, his recent results—coupled with being outpaced by team-mates George Russell and Charles Leclerc across the last couple of seasons—have prompted fresh scrutiny.

The case for stepping away

  • Results: The trophies have dried up compared to his dominant peak.
  • Form vs machinery: Hamilton hasn’t consistently had the car advantage he once enjoyed, amplifying every off-weekend.
  • Voices in the paddock: Former F1 driver David Brabham recently suggested Hamilton should have walked away years ago.

The case for racing on

  • Pedigree: Few drivers manage tyre life, racecraft and development feedback like Hamilton.
  • Ceiling remains high: With the right setup window and strategy roll, he still produces elite stints and recovery drives.
  • Ferrari project: Big team transitions often require time; unlocking performance can flip narratives quickly.

Legacy isn’t one season deep

Whether this is a late-career lull or a platform for resurgence, Hamilton’s legacy is already secure. The real question is whether the Ferrari chapter becomes a coda or a comeback. For now, the grid’s most decorated driver appears committed to proving there’s more to write.

×